kill homophobia by reading this book
A funny thing happened today in our extendo-family message thread. My brother, who had dubbed himself “Guncle” in his profile said a thing and my other brother, (undubbed in his profile) not a Guncle, said it was a funny word. So my funny sister piped up that “Gaunt” is also a funny word and I, always one to push the joke too far, idiotically spiralled the thread out of control and punchlined the bit by asking my sister if this was a way for her to come out to us. This exchange made me think a lot about gay culture and the absence of it in subsections of cis culture and how odd this must feel for queer or gay folk experiencing that void.
That is my newest intro to this review because I have been sitting on this for a week for unknown (ok maybe known but not worked out) reasons. Like: It’s hard to write reviews about difficult books and I don’t even know what my template is for my reviews yet. Are they straightforward reviews or am I talking about myself/life/the world/literature at large in them? A lot of big questions for me! But then I am, like, who cares? Just look at Substack! Everybody is writing the words! Such diversity of words! Throwing a pebble into the ocean here.
This was my previous intro: I read books all the time and think they’re not really necessarily bad, but I don’t have all that much to say about them. But The Disappearers is different. I have a lot to say about it, but I don’t really know how to say it.
The first thing that I can think of saying or talking about is this: People just love sex and violence, but not necessarily gay sex and violence or heaven forbid, gay sex, and gay violence, and there can be only one reason for this: deeply engrained homophobia.
I did not have trouble reading this book because of gay sex, in fact I did not have trouble reading this book at all. It was riveting; the characters real and the plot gripping. The violence is a different story. I do find it hard to read graphic violence. But in this case, the story can’t exist without it.
This was the very first intro: I’ve often had trouble reading devastating novels because at first you can’t be sure if they will have a thread of hopefulness to bind them to you as a reader. But like, Demon Copperhead — a very different devastating novel, The Disappearers holds you to the window you are looking through and will not let you look away.
If we all read books that were just our life experience regurgitated back to us, where would we be? it would be boring and awful and honestly, why would anyone even read fiction? Pointless. We read because it transports us to a different world. And being a black gay man in Jamaica in the late 80’s can be nothing further from my world. BUT Marlon James is such a smart writer. I still found ways to identify instantly with Eddy Porteous, through whose journal we first start seeing these characters as they all come together to rehearse for a play.
I am roughly the same age as Eddy is in this novel, and so against all odds, found myself instantly recognizing key points in his cultural life: Claire Huxtable, The Osmonds, Family Ties, Rob Base. Sinéad O’Connor, Miami Vice — saying that girls think they are cool if they listen to Hounds of Love and The Queen is Dead is not specific to Jamaica, even if in Jamaica it might be more unlikely. Or hating Chris de Burgh’s “Lady in Red” as a touchstone for who is cool and who is not. All these things quickly bound me to Eddy so that I almost didn’t worry about what manner of violence was inevitably coming. I was staying with him.
The novel is told in different perspectives: Eddy’s journal, The Blackjacks testimony, after they commit their atrocity, (this 25 page section is putdown when you can’t and pickup again when you can. But I had to keep going because I had no real internet for 5 days and only this one book far away from other forms of entertainment. I stuck with it.) Then we get to The Disappearers and Jordan Brown circa 1994. His narrative jumps back and forth between his hearing about the death of Kurt Cobain and how this tears him apart and his unbidden memories of the June 1988 horrors that the Blackjacks wrecked on the actors during a rehearsal on Lady Musgrave road. He doesn’t want to talk about it. But next we get the transcripts of the recordings that a journalist for a series with the working title The Disappearers, a documentary of sorts about the Blackjacks and/or violence in the gay community. And Jordon is talking about it. Here, began my soft spot for Jordan, damaged before the gay bashing and pushed to the point of no return after it. He lets no one in and is beholden to no one and so is resistant to the interviews. But he still does them, because above all he wants the truth to out. And justice. Here we learn a lot about the violence that Jordan has experienced in his life before and after the murder and beatings of 1988. But then the interviews change voice and we hear again from Eddy and then, importantly, from Havelock, who, he would say, started the whole thing by wanting to direct a play about gay men in prison.
The Disappearers in the story are 2 of the men that have gone missing since the attack in 1988; they had gone to the hospital with the others and then left and were never heard from again. The bulk of the story centre's around the preoccupation that Jordan and Eddy (who never ended up going to rehearsal that night) have. Both come at it together and separately, for different reasons with Havelock, at first absent, who resurfaces with his story to play his part in the ultimate conclusion.
I feel like I just have to cut and end this here. I don’t have to tell you about the shadows these men lived in or how fear begets hates begets violence begets violence and never ends until love ends it. There’s so much more.
So, in the end, I guess I have decided I’ll not do a play by play, this book is a lot of things, but what it did for me is let me see into a world I would never ever have known otherwise and then changed me for the better.
"When in disgrace with fortune and men's eyes, / I all alone beweep my outcast state, / And trouble deaf heaven with my bootless cries, / And look uроп myself and curse my fate.”
- Smitty to Mona/ Matt to Eddy page 613, The Disappearers
from Fortune and Men’s Eyes by John Herbert


